Post by: The Beast

Here are our picks for the Beautiful Creatures characters:
Picture

ETHAN (actor Dylan Patton)

Picture

LENA (actress Selena Gomez)

Picture

AMMA (actress Alfre Woodard)

Picture

MACON (actor Dermot Mulroney)

Picture

RIDLEY (actress Taylor Momsen)

Picture

LINK (actor Sterling Knight)

Add your own picks in the comments below (feel free to include links to pictures!)
michelle
7/20/2011 01:35:02 am

Lucy Hale for Lena!! She's small, has black hair & green eyes already, and she's an amazing actress! This is the role she was born to play, I really hope she gets cast, it would make the movie that much better!

Reply
sam
3/17/2012 11:00:48 am

lucy hale is a good actor and would be MUCH better then selena gomez without a doubt but shes not how i pictured lena at all. :\

Reply
bluecementicing
7/20/2011 01:44:08 am

no! all wrong, sorry.

but my choices http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hz7c7khZOwU

Reply
Nahla
7/20/2011 03:16:12 am

Don't like the Ethan or Lena :/

Reply
Kimberly
7/20/2011 03:22:03 am

If Gomez plays Lena I would definitely not even go see it.

Reply
Dianna
7/20/2011 03:23:33 am

Logan Lerman is too short to play Ethan. In the books he is 6'2" and Logan is only 5'8".

Lucy Hale would be perfect as Lena. I like the other choices posted here.

Reply
Irene
7/20/2011 03:34:41 am

No offence but i really don't like your picks... apart from Link :) But i do agree with most of bluecementicing's choices!!

Reply
chris
7/20/2011 03:48:42 am

use lucy better choice than selina ugh and ya link has to be someone else but ethan is fine

Reply
Mimi
7/20/2011 03:56:36 am

I don't care for Ethan or Lena or Link or Ridley... I can see Lucy Hale as Lena but I feel like it should be someone less "popular" than her. India Eisley is who I was imagining while I was reading it. Maybe Phoebe Tonkin.

As for Ridley, Rosie Huntington-Whiteley (she's a model and I know she was in Transformers 3 which I haven't seen yet so I can't judge her acting skill) might be good if her hair was a tad lighter. Maybe Jennifer Lawrence, too, or Dianna Agron.

Ethan.. dude, I don't even know. I love Logan Lerman but he's just not right for the role. MAYBE Steven R. McQueen. Maybe.

Jason Dolley would be perfect for Link, in my opinion.

The people for Macon and Amma looked fine to me, though.

Reply
Jessica
7/20/2011 04:12:27 am

No ALL WRONG!
Lena-Lucy Hale she is perfect for her. And she an amazing actress.

Reply
Mw
7/20/2011 04:28:49 am

I don't like this casting at all :S

Reply
Bailey
7/20/2011 04:34:07 am

Lucy Hale for Lena if Selana is Lena I am not going to see it she is just to plain to be Lena

Reply
7/20/2011 04:53:58 am

Hey guys, thanks for all the comments! Remember, if you disagree with our choices - post your own. We look forward to seeing them.

-Book Addict

Reply
Alex
7/20/2011 05:24:10 am

Ethan maybe, Lena definitely no!!!!!!!!! the athers are perfect!!!

Reply
Shelby
7/20/2011 05:24:28 am

Salena shouldn't be Lena I would be so mad and Ethan looks ok so does everyone else but not salena

Reply
KP
7/20/2011 06:18:49 am

Crystal Reed for Lena!

Reply
Andrea
7/20/2011 07:13:20 am

I don't think Selena was such a horrid choice. I liked the rest! :)

Reply
Delilah Wellman
7/20/2011 07:34:11 am

Great!

Reply
Myanna
7/20/2011 10:19:59 am

I dont hate them but there not really how I imagined any of them :/

Reply
Mel Williams
7/20/2011 10:40:49 am

I like all the choices but Lena. Selena Gomez is not who I pictured as Lena. Maybe because I've seen her play more "goofy" characters however Lena does have a goofiness about her. It will be interesting to see how this plays out;)

Reply
Mel Williams
7/20/2011 10:43:54 am

I must say Amma is absolutely PERFECT!

Reply
K. Trahan
7/24/2011 06:43:53 pm

The choices for Lena and Ethan are completely wrong! Steven R. Mcqueen would be undeniably perfect for Ethan, and I have to say, Lucy Hale would be a MUCH better choice for Lena. Really, she would be the ultimate pick.

Reply
Kat
8/3/2011 04:42:16 am

I always imagined Ethan with more of a baby face & Link a little more muscular. I kinda prefer Robert Downy Jr. to play Macon, he's more of a dark person which is perfect. And I love Selena Gomez, dnt get me wrong, but i think someone more with a dark attitude would be better. And i always imagined Lena with a long square face. & Taylor Momsen is ok for Ridley. But remeber thers a bunch of other characters.

Reply
Joseph
8/8/2011 07:10:21 am

i have old wallpapers of the book with Emily Browning as Lena and Logan Lerman as Ethen, i think they should deffinately play those roles, selena gomez is ok but not for this movie i think. I love Momson o.o thats an amazing choice. I think Logan and Emily should have the lead roles strongly, ive been imagining them while reading the book as Ethan and Lena and theyd do amazingly. DO ETT! xD

Reply
Monique
8/8/2011 07:14:28 am

Logan Lerman - Ethen Wate
Emily Browning - Lena Duchannes
<3

Reply
Joe
8/8/2011 07:48:44 am

Joseph again... Don't feel like I said my opinion on all the the characters because I was on my iPod.

Ethen - NONONO! I don't even know who this Dylan Patton kid is but he doesn't really look the part. I seriously do think Logan Lerman should be Ethan Wate, so many people expected him to be and so many people will be disapointed if he's not even approached about it... Unless he has been, there should be something explaining that if he has.

Lena - Selena Gomez is an amazing actress, I love her. But, I can't imagine her for this part at all. Same thing with Logan being Ethan, people have expected Emily Browning as Lena Duchannes and I think she'd be very amazing for this role.

Amma - ... Perfect. o.o

Macon - This guy looks a little too young to play this part. That and he isn't dark enough (personality'ish wise) . he'd look very fake playing this role. whoever is in the picture on the Caster Girl Galeries should play him ( http://castergirls.com/galleries/displayimage.php?album=23&pos=7 ) I don't know who he is but he looks awesome for the role. xD

Ridley - OMG o.o... Are you serious!? APPROVE!!! xD

Link - I don't hate the choice, I imagined Link a little more muscular but I don't think Sterling would do bad, I can deal with this one.

They already had an amazing cast picked out, why not just stick with them, they'd do so perfectly! ( http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/18/beautifulcreatures5byle.jpg/ )... Except Ridley xD I don't care whether they use Momson or the chick that was already chosen, I think they'd both be perfect xD in looks anyways, I know Momson can act, she already fits the role though.

Reply
FaggotDyke
8/8/2011 08:22:15 am

Hmm lets start with Selena, she doesn;t fit the role AT ALL, she fits one of two roles right now; tomboy and rebellious borderline sociopathic teenager that still manages to not curse, drink, or do drugs. I doubt the heroine in any movie now-a-days is going to be remotely like that. And Dylan?... No... Just no, he doesn't fit Ethan at all... Nothing left to say about that. But Taylor Momson o.o.... OMG -fangirlgasm- YUSS!!!

Logan Lerman - Ethen Wate
Emily Browning - Lena Duchannes
<3

Reply
Leigh
8/8/2011 08:41:47 am

Logan Lerman - Ethen Wate
Emily Browning - Lena Duchannes

Reply
8/8/2011 08:56:45 am

Logan Lerman - Ethen Wate
Emily Browning - Lena Duchannes

Reply
SchokoFreak
8/14/2011 01:35:10 am

Ethan- Logan Lerman. I think Lucy Hale should play Lena. Link, Ridley & Amma = perfect but Dermot Mulroney is to young for macon.

Reply
PraireHotness
8/17/2011 05:40:46 am

I don't really none of the characters, especially Dylan Patton, Selena gomez & Sterling Knight.
I though Ethan was gonna be an emo hunk,Lena good-looking (like Lucky Hale, Emily Browning, & Link like a Jock tall kinda hunk but not better than ethan look.
~ i don't really like non its depressing

Reply
gurl
8/17/2011 06:13:36 am

Crystal reed is pathetic 4 lena

Reply
booklover2
8/22/2011 01:08:35 am

Link should NOT be sterling knight.

Reply
anne
8/22/2011 01:40:13 am

Everyone is perfect,except Lena .. I think that the best for this part is Lucy Hale .. if not,then Danielle Campbell

Reply
Megan Fox
8/22/2011 07:32:02 am

I read the first 2 books & the caracters in the movie should be more wow! but gross Dylan Patton, Selena Gomez I know her & she is terrible actress & ugly, Sterling Knight 2 naive 2 have the Link paper, they all suck

Reply
Daria
8/31/2011 09:50:05 am

Ethan and Lena look ALL WRONG, if this was the official casting list I would be so disappointed. I definitely agree with whoever said Steven R. McQueen for Ethan - he looks PERFECT for the part.

And for Selena Gomez, I will flip out if she's in another movie. She's so over rated and we need a fresh face, not some beloved Disney Channel star that gets all the publicity.

Not sure how I feel about Sterling Knight though; he looks just like my interpretation of link but then again he's an over rated Disney Channel star. Different actor with similar looks would be better (:

As for the rest, PERFECT! I actually imagined Taylor Momsen as Ridley in my head anyway, so I'm glad she's on the list!

Reply
Babe!!!
9/4/2011 05:41:58 am

Zac Efron for ethan! Lucy Hale for Lena or Emily Browning!! Selena gomez is childish & not pretty girl material.

Reply
Amanda Jane
9/10/2011 11:46:51 am

i WOULD NOT go see this movie if Gomez is Lena and that other guy is Ethan, even if this is my favorite movie. Knight would be okay for Link. Honestly, I LOOK MORE LIKE LENA THAN GOMEZ. (sorry but true) and as for Ridley, it will be cool if Avril Lavinge played the part even if she might be a bad actor.

Reply
human being
9/13/2011 04:46:59 am

Ethan needs to be this perfect guy out there that hasn't being discovered (why one of does ugly stupid actors? there a bunch of ethan looking guys in use & the world search 4 HIM!!!) lena as lucy hale!! SEARCH 4 ETHAN WATE!!!!!

Reply
bridget
9/13/2011 08:47:36 am

Eathan- Logan Lerman
Lena- Emily browning

Reply
Bianca
10/19/2011 01:24:27 am

Sorry i don't like Ethan or Lena, and i dont like Selena Gomez :/ Sorry!

Reply
11/4/2011 03:22:41 am

Tessa Aliece for the character Lena.

Black hair, blue/green eyes, 117lbs, with a very unique look. She was an extra in the Twilight Saga: Eclipse; a three page featured model for Venus Says Magazine; second place winner in the End Of Summer Swimsuit Shoot Off.

Her facebook page is:
www.facebook.com/tessaaliece

She would be perfect.

Reply
Gaby
12/9/2011 05:19:59 am

Logan Lerman - Ethan Wate
Emily Browning or Lucy Hale - Lena Duchannes

Now they would be perfect for Lena & Ethan :)

Reply
Sarah
12/31/2011 07:03:52 am

Too Me I Like Selena, She Can Act, She Isn't Plain. She Has Her Own Style Like Lena, I Think That Through It All I Like The People That Were Picked. Sure They Aren't What I Expected But I Think Lucy Hale Isn't The Best.

Reply
Yay
1/2/2012 12:52:01 pm

Lena= crystal reed
Ethan= Steven r. McQueen

Reply
Lavinia
1/20/2012 12:34:59 am

Logan Lerman tem que ser Ethan, Lucy Hale tem que ser Lena e Macon tá muito novo. Concordo apenas com Link, o resto tá ridículo !

Reply
Renata
1/23/2012 03:39:48 am

For the cast must be:
Lena: Lucy Hale
Ethan: Logan Lerman (or any other actor, but not Dylan Patton)
Link: Chord Overstreet or Sterling Knight
Ridley: Kristen Bell
Sarafine: Famke Janssen
Amma: Alfre Woodard
Macon: Dermot Mulroney

Reply
Tom
1/24/2012 06:56:34 am

Rumor has it that BRETT DIER is ETHAN

Reply
sam
3/17/2012 10:58:25 am

FAAAAAACKKKK NOOOOOO NO DISNEY PEOPLE OR ILL KILL EVERYONE... dont ruin this book for me

Reply



Leave a Reply.